UBA LOSES APPEAL AS COURT UPHOLDS N9m DAMAGES FOR WRONGFUL ACCOUNT RESTRICTION

Kingsley Ike

The Ondo State High Court, sitting in Okitipupa, has dismissed an appeal filed by United Bank for Africa (UBA) Plc regarding a previous ruling that held the financial institution liable for severe negligence.

The court upheld the judgment of the Okitipupa Chief Magistrate Court, which ordered UBA to pay ₦9 million in general damages and ₦60,000 in costs to a customer, Mr. Felix Oyeneyin. The legal battle stemmed from the bank’s operational handling of a garnishee order, which resulted in the wrongful restriction of the customer’s account for more than six months.

In the judgment, the presiding judge emphasized that while financial institutions are legally bound to comply with valid court orders, they also owe an equal responsibility to diligently verify identity before taking action.

The court held that UBA had a duty of care to establish that the specific account being frozen actually belonged to the individual identified in the relevant legal proceedings. Because the bank failed to conduct this critical verification before freezing the funds, its actions were deemed a clear breach of its professional obligations.

By affirming the ₦9 million penalty, the High Court reinforced the legal precedent that banks cannot hide behind the cover of a court order to justify reckless or sloppy administrative errors. The ruling emphasizes that wrongful account restriction inflicts significant financial injury and emotional distress on consumers. This decisive judgment serves as a stern warning to the banking sector that failing to properly safeguard customer accounts against careless freezes will attract heavy financial penalties.

In a judgment delivered on October 13, 2026 , in appeal number HOK/9A/2025, Justice L.B. Ologun ruled that United Bank for Africa (UBA) Plc failed to exercise reasonable care and diligence before freezing a customer’s funds.

The court found that the bank acted negligently by failing to properly verify details before imposing the restriction, and further compounded the error by failing to act promptly once the customer lodged a formal complaint. Consequently, the High Court held the financial institution fully liable for breaching its professional duty of care.

The legal dispute originally arose after the customer, Mr. Felix Oyeneyin, discovered in January 2023 that he could no longer access the funds in his account at UBA’s Okitipupa branch . According to official court documents, the bank informed him that a lien, or post-no-debit restriction, had been placed on his account. UBA claimed it was acting in compliance with a garnishee order issued by a Lagos Magistrate Court , which legally compelled them to halt transactions.

However, Justice Ologun clarified that while banks are legally required to comply with valid court orders, they also bear a strict responsibility to verify the identity of the account holder before executing such orders.

The court held that UBA had an administrative duty to establish that the frozen account actually belonged to the specific individual identified in the Lagos legal proceedings. Because the bank failed to cross-check this critical data and carelessly restricted the wrong person’s money for over six months, the court upheld the ₦9 million penalty against the institution.

Oyeneyin challenged the restriction, maintaining that he did not know the judgment creditor and had never conducted any transaction with him. He also argued that the garnishee order did not contain his account number or address and lacked other identifying particulars connecting him to the judgment debtor.

Despite his complaint, the restriction remained in place until August 2, 2023, more than six months after he first raised the issue with the bank.

UBA challenged the trial court’s judgment, arguing that it had merely complied with a valid garnishee order issued by a court of competent jurisdiction and therefore could not be held negligent for obeying it.

The bank also argued that a letter written by Oyeneyin’s solicitor amounted to an admission that he was the person involved in the garnishee proceedings. It further contended that the damages awarded against it were excessive.

However, Justice Ologun rejected the bank’s argument that compliance with the court order was sufficient to absolve it of responsibility for the restriction.

“The issue is not about compliance with a valid order of court but about ensuring that a customer that is affected by the order of court is the one whose account is being restricted,” the judge held.

He noted that the garnishee order served on UBA contained only the name “Felix Oyeneyin” without an account number or other identifying particulars linking the order to the customer’s account.

A major factor in the ruling was the testimony of UBA’s sole witness, who admitted under cross-examination that the garnishee order did not contain Mr. Oyeneyin’s account number . Justice L.B. Ologun emphasized that a prudent financial institution would have sought further information to verify the identity of the actual judgment debtor before freezing an innocent customer’s funds.

The judge criticized the bank’s automated approach, stating, “A blanket obedience of court order without due diligence in this circumstance, apparently fractured the hallowed contractual relationship between a bank and its customers”. The court maintained that a reasonable assessment of the legal document should have prompted UBA to demand the debtor’s specific account number or, at the very least, proactively notify Oyeneyin about the development.

The High Court also heavily scrutinized how UBA managed the situation after the restriction was discovered. The judgment noted that Oyeneyin’s testimony—recounting how he spent hours at the Okitipupa branch from 9:00 AM to 2:00 PM demanding answers—went completely uncontroverted.

Furthermore, the bank failed to challenge his assertion that he neither knew nor owed money to the judgment creditor. Rather than acting swiftly to resolve the administrative error, UBA instructed the customer to travel from Okitipupa to Lagos to sort out the issue himself. Rebuking this response, Justice Ologun noted that the bank treated the customer with levity and subjected him to undue hardship, ignoring the duty of reasonable care and skill it owed him.

UBA’s legal defense crumbled further as the court faulted its failure to prove it had complied with the garnishee order’s requirement to file an “affidavit to show cause” within 14 days of service.

Timely compliance would have allowed the issuing court to resolve the mix-up by March 3, 2023; instead, the wrong restriction was left in place until August 2, 2023 . Because UBA failed to produce this critical affidavit, Justice Ologun ruled that the trial court was fully justified in applying Section 167(d) of the Evidence Act, 2011 , which presumes that evidence withheld by a party would be unfavorable to them.

Additionally, the judge rejected UBA’s reliance on a solicitor’s letter to prove Oyeneyin was the debtor, ruling that the document could not conclusively establish identity on its own.

Citing established legal precedents, including the Supreme Court decision in Agbanelo v. UBN Ltd (2000) and GTB Plc v. Yunusa (2024) , the judgment reiterated that a bank’s duty of care spans its entire operations. Resolving all issues against the financial institution, Justice Ologun dismissed the appeal for lack of merit and affirmed the September 29, 2025 trial court judgment .

This leaves intact the original award of ₦9 million in general damages and ₦60,000 in costs against UBA. In the appeal, UBA was represented by Sanmi Owoeye, while Solomon Tunya, E.E. Ojubulu, and B.J. Jolowo represented Oyeneyin. The judgment was delivered on October 13, 2026, with a Certified True Copy (CTC) issued the following day.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *